647 E Market Street, Akron, OH 44304 Call or text 330.573.2738 Tastefulexp1@gmail.com
Tasteful Expectations catering logo, a rose T and a gold E wrapped in a gold ribbon Tasteful
Expectations
330.573.2738 Request a Quote

Home  ›  Catering  ›  Cakes  ›  Custom cakes

Custom Cakes in Akron, Ohio

Made from scratch and decorated to your theme, for birthdays, weddings, showers, graduations and anniversaries, with or without the catering.

From a tenth birthday drip cake to a wedding tier.

A custom cake starts with a conversation: the occasion, the number of guests, the colors, and the thing that makes it theirs. From there it is made from scratch in the same kitchen as our catering, decorated to the theme, and delivered with the rest of the order or on its own.

The drip cake with a movie character on top of our work page was a tenth birthday. Wedding tiers, graduation cakes in school colors, shower cakes to match the invitations and anniversary cakes that repeat the original are all the same craft at a different scale.

Dessert pricing starts at $6 per person. Tell us the date, the guest count and the idea and we come back with a design and a number.

Custom tenth birthday cake with red drip icing, a movie character figure and Welcome to Double Digits lettering

Cakes for the way Akron celebrates.

Akron celebrates in a predictable calendar. Graduation cakes in late May and June for the eight Akron Public Schools high schools, the Catholic schools and the University. Shower cakes through spring and fall. Birthday cakes every weekend of the year, from first birthdays in Ellet to seventieths in Fairlawn Heights. Wedding cakes for receptions from Stan Hywet’s gardens on Portage Path to the halls on Akron Peninsula Road.

Cakes are picked up from the kitchen at 647 E Market Street or delivered with a catering order anywhere in the service area. A tiered cake travels assembled only so far, so for Canton, Kent, Medina or Cleveland we can finish the stacking on site.

Bring a photo, a color swatch or an invitation. The design conversation starts from whatever you have.

What comes with it.

Birthday cakes

Drip cakes, character cakes and number cakes decorated to the theme, for kids and milestones.

Wedding cakes

Tiered cakes designed around the colors and flavors, delivered and finished on site.

Shower and graduation cakes

Matched to the invitation or the school colors, often alongside a dessert table.

Sheet cakes

For a repast, a retirement or a company anniversary, decorated and delivered with the meal.

What Akron says.

GoogleRated 5.0 from 7 reviews

Read every review on Google

This place offers ALL of your catering needs. I don't believe there is anything she can't provide for you. I have had SO many meals and attended SO many events. The Taste of the City (Akron) she provided so many great "samples". An outdoor hibachi grill party with all the trimmings, steak, shrimp, chicken, rice, fresh vegetables also one of my favorites. The taco bar and loaded potatoes are great for staff meetings. The seafood is always top quality, the largest shrimp! The desserts made from scratch are amazing. Cakes, cheesecakes, individual desserts, it doesn't end. Give them a try! Best prices around with professional service.
Ava WalkerGoogle review, a year ago

Before you book.

How far ahead should a custom cake be ordered?
Two weeks for most cakes, longer for a wedding tier or a detailed design. Graduation season and December fill early. Send the date and the idea and we confirm what is possible.
Can I order a cake without catering?
Yes. Cakes are ordered on their own for pickup from the kitchen on East Market Street or delivered. Many also ride along with a catering order so there is one delivery on the day.
What flavors and fillings do you offer?
Classic flavors with fillings and frostings to match, built to the occasion. Tell us what the guest of honor loves and we design around it. Allergies and dietary needs go on the request form.
Do you deliver tiered cakes and set them up?
Yes. Tiered cakes are delivered and finished on site inside Akron and across the service area. For longer drives we stack the final tiers at the venue so nothing arrives leaning.

All nine questions

Two ways to start.

Know your date, headcount and menu direction? Send the short form and we will call you. Prefer to give us everything at once? Use the full catering request.

Tasteful Expectations, LLC.
647 E Market Street
Akron, OH 44304 330.573.2738 Tastefulexp1@gmail.com
Every request gets a reply within three to five business days.

Call 330.573.2738 Request a quote
Request a Quote