647 E Market Street, Akron, OH 44304 Call or text 330.573.2738 Tastefulexp1@gmail.com
Tasteful Expectations catering logo, a rose T and a gold E wrapped in a gold ribbon Tasteful
Expectations
330.573.2738 Request a Quote

Home  ›  Catering  ›  Cakes

Custom, Wedding and Birthday Cakes in Akron, Ohio

Made from scratch and decorated to your theme, ordered on their own or with the catering and the dessert table from the same kitchen.

The cake comes from the kitchen that made dinner.

Most caterers send you to a bakery. Our cakes are made from scratch in the same kitchen as the catering, which is why couples and families book us for the whole table: one delivery, one setup, one person to call on the day. The cakes are also ordered on their own, picked up from East Market Street or delivered.

Custom cakes cover birthdays, showers, graduations and anniversaries. Wedding cakes are designed around the colors, the flavors and the guest count. Birthday cakes run from a first birthday smash cake to a milestone that needs a sheet cake beside it.

Dessert pricing starts at $6 per person. Bring a photo, a swatch or an invitation and the design conversation starts there.

Three kinds of cake.

Each has its own page. All three come from the same oven.

Custom cakes

Made from scratch for birthdays, weddings, showers and graduations.

Custom cakes in Akron

Wedding cakes

Designed around your colors, flavors and guest count.

Wedding cakes in Akron

Birthday cakes

Custom designs, flavors and sizes for any guest count.

Birthday cakes in Akron
Overhead view of a catering dessert table filled with banana pudding cups, cherry cheesecake cups, brownies and lemon bars

The cake sits in the middle of a table like this one.

See more from real events

Akron orders cakes by the calendar.

Graduation cakes arrive in a wave from late May through June, one school color scheme after another from Buchtel to Walsh Jesuit. Wedding cakes follow the reception calendar at Stan Hywet on Portage Path, the ballrooms on Akron Peninsula Road and East Waterloo, and the lodges out toward Peninsula. Birthday cakes never stop.

Tiered cakes travel assembled across Akron, Fairlawn, Cuyahoga Falls, Stow and Green from the kitchen at 647 E Market Street. For Kent, Canton, Medina and Cleveland we can finish the top tiers at the venue so nothing arrives leaning.

Shower cakes, anniversary cakes and sheet cakes for a repast or a company milestone are all on the custom cakes page.

What comes with it.

Order with catering

The cake rides along with the dinner, the brunch or the dessert table on one delivery.

Order on its own

Pickup from the kitchen on East Market Street or delivery to your home or venue.

Design from anything

A photo, a color swatch, an invitation or a theme is enough to start.

Dietary needs

Allergies and dietary needs go on the request form so the recipe is built to them.

What Akron says.

GoogleRated 5.0 from 7 reviews

Read every review on Google

This place offers ALL of your catering needs. I don't believe there is anything she can't provide for you. I have had SO many meals and attended SO many events. The Taste of the City (Akron) she provided so many great "samples". An outdoor hibachi grill party with all the trimmings, steak, shrimp, chicken, rice, fresh vegetables also one of my favorites. The taco bar and loaded potatoes are great for staff meetings. The seafood is always top quality, the largest shrimp! The desserts made from scratch are amazing. Cakes, cheesecakes, individual desserts, it doesn't end. Give them a try! Best prices around with professional service.
Ava WalkerGoogle review, a year ago

Before you book.

Do you make wedding cakes as well as cater weddings?
Yes, and usually both for the same wedding. The cake and the dessert table come from the kitchen that makes the dinner, so there is one vendor on the day. The cake can also be ordered alone.
How far ahead should a cake be ordered in Akron?
Two weeks for most custom and birthday cakes, longer for a wedding tier with a detailed design. The busiest stretches are late May through June and the first three weeks of December, so for those, send the date as soon as you have it.
Can you match a cake to a theme or a photo?
Yes. Send the photo, the colors or the invitation with the request. The cake is designed and decorated in house to match.
Can I pick up a cake from your kitchen?
Yes. Pickup is from 647 E Market Street in Akron at a time you choose. Tiered and large cakes are better delivered, and we will tell you which when we confirm.

All nine questions

Two ways to start.

Know your date, headcount and menu direction? Send the short form and we will call you. Prefer to give us everything at once? Use the full catering request.

Tasteful Expectations, LLC.
647 E Market Street
Akron, OH 44304 330.573.2738 Tastefulexp1@gmail.com
Every request gets a reply within three to five business days.

Call 330.573.2738 Request a quote
Request a Quote